There is a distinction between criticism and shaming. I mention this in response to the following post from FaceBook:
The need to criticize anyOne is a projection of the belief that you are not good enough. Likewise, taking another person’s criticism of you personally, it’s a reflection of the same belief.
While you are already as Divine as you’re ever going to get, (and there’s nothing you can do in this or any lifetime to change your true identity), you can never live up to an idea of how any person thinks you should be.
This is because thought cannot create the experience of wholeness. It’s only capable of creating elusive stories of wholeness that evoke criticism.
So, the next time you find your self projecting or defending against criticism, you’re invited to illuminate the core issue by noticing the mental story about who you are and how you’re meant to be. This noticing can dismantle the false sense of self and and allow you to create more harmony in all of your relationships.
What a blessing criticism is. Bring it on!!
The above commentary is “a good start.” However, what about the distinction between criticism and shaming?
To even be referencing criticism in the above way is an indication of the operation of shame (which is extremely common and no cause for shame!). Shame involves a fear of being revealed. Let’s look another layer deeper at a fear of being revealed or exposed:
When I fear being revealed, then I may shame others for their actions and inactions and so on. Which instances does the one ashamed point to with most ferocity (fear)? When ashamed, I would point at the instances where “they” do the same thing that I am ashamed of having done in order to bring attention to their alleged shame and distract from mine (or to test the response of other people to me saying whatever, like this: “did you know that Ron Paul used to EAT FISH!?!?! That is SOOOOO disgusting, isn’t it? I haven’t eaten fish for 2 decades now and he was just eating some a few years ago. Can you believe his pompous audacity?”)
On the other hand, criticism is any explicit redirection: “Oh honey, if you are going to get off on exit 43, then the turn lane is over there. Do you see the turn lane?” For the one who is ashamed, even such a gentle exercise of authority (“input”) may be “cause” for annoyance.
If I am already ashamed (afraid of showing fear, error, fallibility), I might say something quite shaming in response to even the gentlest criticism: “Seriously, why do you always have to criticize my driving? You are such a $*(k!ng punk, Gramma. I can’t believe I have to drive you around for the next three weekends. Jesus, what the hell did I ever do so wrong to deserve this? Anyway, why do you have to be so old? Why did you have to lose your license to drive?” So, with that shaming is grievance and grief and fear and shouts that may cover up tears, at least for a while.
Criticism focuses on a process. Shaming focuses on an identity. Shaming involves a ferocious fear or paranoia or hysteria.
Both have their place, by the way- or they would not exist, right? By the way, isn’t it interesting how fast we may criticize others for the activity of shaming? That could be a sign of hypocrisy. 😉
Related articles
- Fear (hmmivegotaquestion.wordpress.com)
- Shame is a Useless Emotion (tinagilbertson.wordpress.com)
- Letting Go of Shame (blogher.com)
- Ten Ways Shame Manifests in Your Life – Study Guide 3 (readingremy.com)
- “Stay in your prison of fear” (dschmus.wordpress.com)
- Living In A Bubble World, and Primary and Secondary Emotions. (faithandmeow.wordpress.com)
- Why do I feel shame when I make a purchase for myself? (brownvagabonder.com)
- just the right amount of weird. (overexposedandunderdeveloped.com)
- Gramma Sutra meets Vibrant Nation (welsh.typepad.com)
- Forgive me, Father; I Forgive my Father (nogutsgodsglory.wordpress.com)
- Have Guilt & Condemnation Taken Over Your Life? (momrpkf.wordpress.com)
- Moving on From Shame. ~ Nikki Di Virgilio (elephantjournal.com)
- A World Without Shame (speaklife1.wordpress.com)
- The True Self and the Story of Me (fatherstephen.wordpress.com)
- Isaiah 54:4 Bible Verse for the Day (momsfirstscreenn.wordpress.com)
- Toxic Shame: We’re Not Gonna Wear It! (cherilynclough.com)
- Shame is a useless, yet common, emotion (newlifeparties.com)
- Evangelicals, Don’t Be Ashamed… A New Commentary Series Called the Evangelical Exegetical Commentary (zwingliusredivivus.wordpress.com)
- Words: What drives you? Guilt, Fear & Shame (ryanadnin.wordpress.com)
- QOTD: Are You Ashamed To Admit You Masturbate? (clutchmagonline.com)
- Secrets (tylerhayes.net)
- Stalking Your Fear. ~ Ana Forrest (elephantjournal.com)
- Hypocrisy (theburningplatform.com)
- The foundation of healing mental ills and of becoming a mature human adult (beyondmeds.com)
- Empowering Your Life – The Difference between Humility and Humiliation Part 2 (secondchancetolive.wordpress.com)
- shame and poisoning dandelions – (yellowhousecafe.wordpress.com)
- Sermonette: Ashamed of the Gospel (worthyofthegospel.wordpress.com)
- Shameful Bodies (apologus.wordpress.com)
- My Own Worst Enemy (confessionsofableedingheart.wordpress.com)
- Yet Not I (fatherstephen.wordpress.com)
- Fear of Rejection (joberlynmanaois.wordpress.com)
- Practicing Transformation (the-gypsy-life.com)
- Meandering with Moses (4) (mtsweat.com)
- Acting Our Age: Priceless! (ezerwoman.wordpress.com)
- Holiness and the fear of God (Isaiah 6) (barefootpreachr.org)
- The Politics of American Perceptions (Column) (popmatters.com)
- Against Diluting Censorship (mediumdifficulty.com)
- Because you never know {at least that’s what I tell myself} (messymiddle.com)
- General Conspiracies – Re: The Paul’s are Traitor’s (disclose.tv)
- Ron Paul Wins the Coveted Scarborough Vote (And Should Have Swept the Right in General) (reason.com)
- The Ron Paul Movement Is Already Breaking Down (businessinsider.com)
- Ron Paul to avoid supporters’ dueling pre-convention rallies (rawstory.com)
- Ron Paul Exposed as a Hypocrite (economicpolicyjournal.com)
- Yeah, I voted for Ron Paul. I voted for him three times and I’m damn glad I did (capitolhillblue.com)
- Carol Paul on Ron Paul Radio: Rand Didn’t Consult Family on Romney Endorsement! Ron Still TRUE (sgtreport.com)
- The Alex Jones double standard-bearers (fauxcapitalist.com)
- Ron Paul to John McCain: Syria is none of our business! (sgtreport.com)
- Ron Paul Delegates Disqualified From The Republican National Convention – WTF ? (theaveragejoenewsblogg.com)
- ‘Burn in hell Rand:’ The son faces the wrath of Ron Paul’s cult-like following (capitolhillblue.com)
- Rand’s Romney Endorsement Focused Around 2016 Presidential Run (12160.info)
- Actually, Ron Paul Is Secretly Winning A Lot More Delegates Than You Think (dailypaul.com)
- Ron Paul, Rupert Murdoch and Barney Frank All Know the War on Drugs is a Failure (libertycrier.com)
- 19. Four For Freedom (12160.info)
- Quorum shortfall shows deep rift in Alaska GOP (juneauempire.com)
- Ron Paul’s Task (lewrockwell.com)
- To all “RON PAUL” voters – I urge you to vote for RON PAUL – that will be a vote for OBAMA!!! (bonjupatten.com)
- Four for freedom… By: Chuck Baldwin (gunnyg.wordpress.com)
- Ron Paul in the Congressional Baseball Hall of Fame (ronpaulnews.net)
- Ron Paul for President, 2016 (lewrockwell.com)
- Four For Freedom by Chuck Baldwin, June 21, 2012 (ireport.cnn.com)
- Why do Street Live? (dailycandyfloss.wordpress.com)
- Mark 4.35-41 “Sofa Sleeping” JUMC 20120625 (mysundaysermons.com)
- Gringo’s Wall of Shame: Get used to it Gringos VOL. IV (bigsoccer.com)
- Baa Baa Black Sheep… (1000mileswithjesus.org)
- Loving You For Who You Are – Happy Easter! (beneaththetangles.wordpress.com)
- When the Storms of Life are Raging (dreamprayact.com)
- In the Boat (drewdowns.net)
- Responses to Nakedness (last time!) (tamimyer.wordpress.com)
- Fear Is What We Cherish: “Fear and worry are not mere emotions; they are expressions of what we hold dear.” (bearveracity.com)
- It’s A Set Up! (jeweldiamondtaylor.wordpress.com)
- Boring Church and the Vulnerable God (theprayinglife.com)
- Fear Not (cjhines.wordpress.com)
- Jesus, I Come (musingsinmontage.wordpress.com)
- The Judge (divinechioma.wordpress.com)
- Connected… but Alone? (lettersfromthetop.com)
- A Lesson From Luke 5 (notsoprivatemusings.wordpress.com)
- Shamed! (peterjfoster.wordpress.com)
- Ashamed of the Gospel? (veritasmizzou.wordpress.com)
- Nakedness and shame (leithart.com)
- Prisoner of Shame (cupofblessing.wordpress.com)
- Escaping the Fear, Shame and Blame Game (cherilynclough.com)
- Shame on You: Guilt and Shame (27freezone.wordpress.com)
- Different types of Modesty & Shyness (lifeofummaslam.wordpress.com)
- No Time for Shame: A Lesson from My Father (iseekpeace83.wordpress.com)
- Combating Shame (toddlohenry.com)
Tags: criticism, distinction, Fear, jesus, ron paul, shame, shaming
July 5, 2012 at 8:02 pm |
Many of your posts are just too heavy for me, but this one I quite enjoyed.
Well reasoned.
Just a ‘shame’ I don;t understand all the others. 😉
July 5, 2012 at 8:10 pm |
Glad this one worked for you. One of my latest, “the power of language” is rather accessible. You already know the reality of my references, though the specific way I talk may be unfamiliar- but there are not a lot of technical terms in that one.
That is a video when I just talk freely about the subject with no script, and other videos may be more or less concise, but video or audio always offers more than just written words, plus lots of my content is disturbing to various ideals regarding economics, governments, religion, and propaganda. If you do not mind “disturbing subject matter” (just contrary to popular mythology, not like gruesome images or something), let me know and I will send you something that I have not published yet (and may not).